|
Evaluating an Argument |
|
| |
|
(Preparation for class) |
|
(In class activities) |
| Week 1 |
|
Aug
21
|
1 |
-- |
|
- Introduction to Course Policies and Goals
- Introduce in-class writing assignment for 8/23.
|
|
Aug
23
|
2 |
- Prepare in-class writing assignment according to directions.
|
|
- Do in-class writing assignment.
|
|
Aug
25
|
3 |
- Read Chapter 1 (3-23) in Writing Arguments (WA).
- Read pages 286-93 in WA.
- Do exercise on page 293.
|
|
- What is a good argument?
- Discuss exercise on p.293.
- Introduce Evaluation Essay Assignment.
|
|
| Week 2 |
|
Aug
28
|
4 |
- Read pp.442-4 in WA.
- Do Task 1, p.443.
|
|
Evaluation is a Criteria Match.
Review responses to Task 1, p.443.
Do Task 2, p.444 in class.
|
|
Aug
30
|
5 |
Do Task 3, pp.444-50 in WA |
|
Do Task 4, p.450 in class.
Develop and defend criteria for good argumentation.
|
|
Sep
1
|
6 |
Read Chapter 2 (24-35) in WA.
Read pp. 295-6 in WA.
|
|
How "Says and Does"helps you understand what you
read.
Do exercise on p.34 in class.
|
|
| Week 3 |
|
Sep
4
|
7 |
-- |
|
No Class -- Labor Day |
|
Sep
6
|
8 |
- Read "Marijuana for Medical Purposes" in Expository
Writing 200 (EW 200), pp. 167-8.
- Write "says" and "does" statements for
each paragraph. (Your goal: to understand the argument's major
claims and how it is put together.)
|
|
- Understanding the How and What of an Argument.
- Discussion of essay and "says" and "does"
statements.
|
|
Sep
8
|
9 |
- Read EW200, pp.93-99, 102-105.
- Write "says" and "does" for one of the
sample essays.
|
|
- Review Student Samples (EW200).
- Organization of Evaluation Essays.
- Evidence in Evaluation Essays: Quoting from your source.
|
|
| Week 4 |
|
Sep
11
|
10 |
- Read WA, pp.435-42.
- Complete "Organizing Your Evaluation Essay" in
EW200, pp.95-7.
- Reminder: First draft due 9/13.
|
|
- More on evidence in Evaluation Essays.
- Learning about Peer Review and linking review comments to
grading/passing criteria.
|
|
Sep
13
|
11 |
- Bring three copies of first draft for Peer Review.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
- More on linking review comments to Grading/Passing Criteria.
- Leave with a revision plan.
|
| Sep 15 |
12 |
- Bring three copies of second draft for Peer Review.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
- Leave with a revision plan.
|
Components of Argument
|
| Week 5 |
|
Sep
18
|
13 |
- Read Chapter 4 (81-94) in WA.
- Do exercises on pp.84-5, pp.87-8.
- Evaluation Essay due by 4pm to DE108.
|
|
- Transition to a detailed understanding of arguments.
- Exercise on p.91 in class.
|
|
Sep
20
|
14 |
- Read Chapter 5 (95-112) in WA
- Do exercise on p.98, #1-6, in WA.
|
|
- Structure of Argument: Claims, Stated Reasons, Grounds, Warrants,
Backing, Rebuttals, and Qualifiers.
- Review exercise on p.98 in WA.
|
|
Sep
22
|
15 |
- Do exercise on p.106 of WA, choosing 2 of the remaining 9
enthymemic arguments.
|
|
- More on Structure of Argument.
- Review responses to exercise on p.106.
|
Proposal Arguments: How to Change Reality
|
| Week 6 |
|
Sep
25
|
16 |
- Read Chapter 14 (304-38) in WA.
|
|
- Introduce Proposal Essay assignment.
- Proposals: We should/should no do X.
- Rhetorical situations.
- Practical vs. Policy Proposals.
|
|
Sep
27
|
17 |
- Bring three possible topics written out to hand in. Have
one that you are fairly sure about and two for back-up.
|
|
- Finding an issue for a proposal.
- Who is your rhetorical audience?
- Do exercise on p.317 in class.
|
|
Sep
29
|
18 |
- Read Chapter 7 (145-65) in WA.
- Do exercises on pp.148-9 and p.164.
|
|
- Audience-Based Reasons.
- Discuss responses to exercises on pp.148-9 and p.164.
- Do exercise on p. 151 in class.
|
|
| Week 7 |
|
Oct
2
|
19 |
- With your topic for your proposal essay in mind, write out
answers to questions about "Audience-Based Reasons"
on pp.149-50 of WA and write out answers to "Stock Issues"
on pp.314-5 of WA.
|
|
- More on Audience-Based Reasons.
|
|
Oct
4
|
20 |
- Read pp.143-46 in EW200.
- Do "says and does" for the two essays.
|
|
- How Proposals are presented and organized.
|
|
Oct
6
|
21 |
- Bring three copies of first draft for Peer Review.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
- Linking Review comments to grading/passing criteria.
- Leave with a Revision Plan.
|
|
| Week 8 |
|
Oct
9
|
22 |
- Bring three copies of second draft for Peer Review.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
- Determine readings for next assignments.
- Leave with a Revision Plan.
|
|
Oct
11
|
23 |
- Proposal due by 4pm to DE 108.
|
|
- Introduce Researched Debate Essay.
|
|
Oct
13
|
24 |
- Topic: "Sexual Harassment: When is Offensiveness a Civil
Offense?"
- Read Riger, "Gender Dilemmas in Sexual Harassment Policies
and Procedures" (WA 581-595) and Chamallas, "Universal
Truth and Multiple Perspectives: Controversies on Sexual Harassment"
(WA 607-611).
-
- Do exercise on p.455 ("Questions for Analyzing and Evaluating
a Conversation") for the two essays.
|
|
- Discuss Riger and Chamallas.
-
- Review responses to exercise on p.455.
|
Researched Debate
|
| Week 9 |
|
Oct
16
|
25 |
- Read Jong, "Fear of Flirting" (WA 599-602), Morgenson,
"Watch That Leer, Stifle That Joke" (WA 602-5), and
Crawford, "A Wink Here, a Leer There: It's Costly"
(WA 606-7).
-
- Do exercise on pp.455-6 ("Questions for Analyzing and
Evaluating an Individual Argument") for one of the three
essays.
-
- Submit essay for Midterm Portfolio Review.
|
|
- Discuss Jong, Morgenson, and Crawford.
-
- Review responses to exercise on pp.455-6.
-
- Determine several "issue questions" for debate
topic.
|
|
Oct
18
|
26 |
- Read pp.380-414 in WA.
-
- Do exercise on p.394.
|
|
- Review of main claims of five essays on sexual harassment.
-
- Using sources effectively and avoiding plagiarism.
-
- Review of exercise on p.394.
|
|
Oct
20
|
27 |
- --
|
|
FALL BREAK -- No Classes |
|
| Week 10 |
|
Oct
23
|
28 |
- Read pp.115-17 and pp.123-26 in EW200.
-
- Begin drafting your outline for your debate essay using theflow
chart on p.116 or the outline on p.117.
|
|
- Review student samples on pp.123-26 of EW200.
|
|
Oct
25
|
29 |
- Bring three copies of your debate essay flow chart/outline
to class for peer review.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
Leave with a Revision Plan.
|
|
Oct
27
|
30 |
- Bring three copies of your draft of your debate essay for
Peer Review.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
Leave with a Revision Plan.
|
Persuasive Research Paper
|
| Week 11 |
|
Oct
30
|
31 |
- Researched Debate due by 4pm to DE108.
|
|
- Introduce Persuasive Research Paper.
|
|
Nov
1
|
32 |
- Read pp.63-70 in WA.
-
- Choose your topic for your research paper and the position
you will take on that topic. Write both out on separate paper
to turn in. Begin to look for your 4-6 sources.
|
|
- Organizational patterns for research reports; review p. 65
in WA.
|
|
Nov
3
|
33 |
- Read two sample student research essays on pp.26-32 in Prairie
Lights 2000.
|
|
- Review sample research essays.
|
|
| Week 12 |
|
Nov
6
|
34 |
- Bring three copies of first draft for Peer Review Session.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
- Linking Review Comments to grading/passing criteria.
|
|
Nov
8
|
35 |
- Bring three copies of second draft for Peer Review Session.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
|
|
Nov
10
|
36 |
- Work on final draft of Persuasive Research Paper.
|
|
- No Class
|
|
Are You Persuaded?: Some Controversial Argumentative
Strategies
|
| Week 13 |
|
Nov
13
|
37 |
- Bring copy of revised draft to class.
-
- Persuasive Research Paper due by 4pm Tuesday to DE108.
|
|
- General workshop on integrating and citing sources and other
questions.
|
|
Nov
15
|
38 |
- Read Lyman, "The Fraternal Bond As Joking Relationship"
and Kimmel, "Clarence, William, Iron Mike, Tailhook, Senator
Packwood, Spur Posse, Magic ...and Us" in the Course Pack
[CP].
|
|
- Discuss Lyman and Kimmel.
|
|
Nov
17
|
39 |
- Read Palac, "How Dirty Pictures Changed My Life"
[CP].
|
|
- Discuss Palac.
|
|
| Week 14 |
|
Nov
20
|
40 |
- Read Vazquez, "Appearances" [CP] and "Of Microbes
and Manhood" [CP]
|
|
- Discuss Vazquez and "Of Microbes and Manhood."
|
|
Nov
22
|
-- |
-- |
|
- NO CLASS
|
|
Nov
24
|
-- |
-- |
|
- THANKSGIVING BREAK
|
|
| Week 15 |
|
Nov
27
|
41 |
- Read Brail, "The Price of Admission: Harassment and
Free Speech in the Wild, Wild West" [CP] and Gleik, "This
Is Safe Sex?" (WA 527-29)
|
|
- Discuss Brail and Gleik.
|
|
Nov
29
|
42 |
- Prepare for in-class essay on Controversial Argumentative
Strategies.
|
|
- Write in-class essay on
- Controversial Argumentative
- Strategies.
|
|
Dec
1
|
43 |
- Read p.175 in EW200.
|
|
- Introduction to "Letter to Portfolio
- Reader"
- Review Student Samples:Common
- Organizational Patterns and Details
- to Support Claims.
|
|
| Week 16 |
|
Dec
4
|
44 |
- Prepare a written thesis statement and outline for your letter
for review in class.
|
|
- Planning session for Letter and
- Gathering Evidence.
|
|
Dec
6
|
45 |
- Revise outline and lists of examples in preparation for in-class
writing.
|
|
- Write "Letter to Portfolio Reader"
- in class.
|
|
Dec
8
|
46 |
- Prepare revisions to existing drafts in preparation for Final
Portfolio Review.
|
|
- Draft workshop, assignment of your choice.
|
|
| Finals Week |
|
Mon
Dec
11
|
|
- 10-12:00 noon, Final Portfolios due to DE108.
|
|
|