June 5, 2013
Step by step: How can we mitigate the risk of slips, trips and falls?
You may not think strolling down the hall to a meeting or taking the stairs to visit the purchasing department is very hazardous. After all, you have been walking for most of your life. However, despite decades of experience performing this simple act, thousands of workers are injured on the job every year from a slip, trip or fall.
In 2011, slips, trips and falls were the second most common event or exposure leading to a work injury or illness — behind overexertion and bodily reaction — accounting for an incidence rate of 29.7 injuries per 10,000 full-time workers, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
These injuries carry a steep cost. Combined, falls on the same level and falls to a lower level were the number one cause of all disabling injury costs in 2010, representing one-quarter of the total and costing employers nearly $14 billion, according to Liberty Mutual Research Institute for Safety in Hopkinton, Mass. People don’t understand how big of a deal it is as far as how many people are getting injured. As a result, they don’t spend much time thinking about what we can do to fix it.
Injury figures related to slips, trips and falls seem to suggest that workers still have not quite mastered walking. We walk all the time, so why can’t we walk without falling? At the heart of the issue is frequency. The high frequency of walking increases the exposure to risks. A whole lot more people are walking on the same level down a hallway or on a manufacturing floor, compared with how many people are using ladders. The amount of exposure is so much greater as far as how much time a person is doing it. Adding to the problem is that because we walk so much, we may not necessarily be thinking about the task of walking. As a result, we can become distracted — similar to how we can while driving — and stop paying attention to hazards.
Blame versus control
Some employers may not recognize slips, trips and falls as being a risk to workers, even though those same employers — particularly in the retail industry — are likely very careful to prevent their customers from being exposed to such hazards. For example, a situation in which a milk carton is spilled in a grocery store — employers are alerted to the aisle for cleanup to prevent shoppers from slipping and falling. However, when it comes to employee areas, that same type of alarm is not always sounded.
Some employers may have a tendency to blame the worker for falling — because they are overweight, not paying attention or just plain clumsy. Although inattention plays a role in the occurrence of slips, trips and falls, it is only one aspect. Physiological characteristics of the walker, such as age or physical disabilities, can lead to slips, trips and falls, and we cannot control these factors. On the other hand, many of the causes are factors that can be controlled, such as unclean floors, appropriate floor care products and employee training. In order to reduce the number of slips, trips and falls in the workplace, focus on instituting a comprehensive approach that addresses those factors that can be manipulated and otherwise controlled.
Several steps can be taken to mitigate the risks of slips, trips and falls. Although workplace floors should have good slip-resistant qualities, many organizations put little thought into flooring when remodeling. For example, a food product warehouse in which the owner had installed a polished concrete floor so slippery it caused forklift wheels to spin on the floor. Had they done a little more planning ahead of time, they could have put the right floor in and reduced the hazard. Select a walkway surface material that will perform well under expected conditions. For instance, certain surfaces are very slip-resistant when dry or clean but can lose some of those properties when wet.
Poorly lit environments also contribute to slips, trips and falls. Conduct a lighting evaluation to determine if surfaces can adequately be seen indoors, outdoors and at night. A combination of mats may be needed on slippery surfaces, such as one to remove debris and another to remove moisture. Although mats can be an effective tool in a slips, trips and falls prevention program, they must be used properly. It’s not just as simple as throwing down a mat. You have to have a process in place. Ask employees what types of mats are needed, where the mats are needed and how long the travel distance is. Additionally, ensure a good maintenance program is in place for the mats, which can become saturated with water or develop worn edges.
A good self-inspection program to maintain floor condition is necessary, including one ensuring walkways are free from objects that could cause a slip, trip or fall. ut an effective floor and housecleaning program is important as well. Ask the floor manufacturer about the best way to clean the floor. Failing to follow instructions for cleaning chemicals is a common mistake. When a spill occurs, workers generally do a good job of placing warning signs around floors that are wet and being cleaned. The problem is that some people may leave those warning signs up long after the floor is dry, leading other employees to begin ignoring the signs.
Employee footwear is another often-overlooked factor in preventing slips, trips and falls. A lot of fast-food places have gone to issuing slip resistant shoes for employees because they know how critical that is, but most employers don’t think in those terms. It may not make much sense for some worksites, such as office environments, to pay for shoes. However, in some work environments rules may be necessary to ensure safe footwear is worn, such as requiring laboratory personnel to wear closed toe shoes to prevent or reduce chemical exposure to their feet in the event of a chemical spill. Furthermore, different jobs may call for different types of footwear. For example, landscapers should probably use a shoe or boot with deep tread and large cleats to prevent slips, trips and falls. In general, footwear that more closely resembles a tennis shoe is likely to provide better grip and prevention from slips, trips and falls.
Stairwells are another area with serious risks for slips, trips and falls. Provide adequate lighting in stairwells, and ensure steps have a good grip and are maintained. Train employees on how to properly use the handrail. SAIF Corp., a state chartered workers’ compensation insurance provider for Oregon, recommends turning 30 degrees toward the handrail when using the stairs. In the event of a fall, most people fall in the direction they are facing, so this positioning would send the person into the rail instead of down the steps. Hang posters that demonstrate how to hold the handrail properly and discourage employees from running up or down the stairs.
Several small changes can be made to minimize slip, trip and fall hazards. For example, one worksite where new, improperly trained janitorial workers mistakenly believed adding more of a certain chemical to a cleaning solution would make the floors cleaner. Instead, the solution left a slippery film on the tile. However, once the employer provided training on the recommended amount of cleaner, the floors became less slippery. Simple solutions such as this can come from having discussions with employees about hazards in the workplace and what can be done to prevent them.
Recently, Tim Ford, a senior safety specialist at Cornell University in Ithaca, N.Y., was confronted with a series of near misses and minor injuries as people walked through a skywalk connecting two buildings. He spoke with employees and learned that when temperatures inside the skywalk grew very warm, people would open the windows. Then, when it rained, the floor would became slick and people would slip.
"By talking and investigating with employees, the simple solution was to fix the temperature," Ford said. "That was all from listening to employees."
Such buy-in from employees and upper management is similar to how any safety issue should be approached. To create a safer environment free of slip, trip and fall hazards, we need to instill a culture change. Such a culture change is not limited to any particular industry. When SAIF Corp. found out that it needed to reduce its own slip, trip and fall incidences, it created a buy-in program within the organization, starting from the top down. They set some expectations for their office employees, and they all as a group held each other accountable, and that reduced their slips, trips and falls.